Decision reflects community feedback and commitment to inclusivity

KINCARDINE, ON –  Following community engagement and careful consideration, the Municipality of Kincardine Council has made the decision to decommission the Secord Monument.

The Secord Monument has been the subject of significant debate in recent months, with many community members expressing concerns about its presence in the community due to its historical associations. Council’s decision aims to respect these concerns while maintaining the Municipality’s commitment to being a welcoming and inclusive community for all residents.

There was consideration of the reinstallation of the monument either in its original location or in an alternate space with additional historical context. The resulting discussion concluded that attempting to have the monument serve as an educational piece for the public would be ineffective and possibly glorify past atrocities inadvertently. In addition, multiple locations were approached about the possibility of hosting the monument and all declined to accept.

A thoughtful and inclusive discussion

“We understand that this decision may not satisfy everyone,” said Mayor Kenneth Craig. “However, after listening to our community, it became clear that there was no appropriate place to display the Secord Monument that would align with our values of inclusivity and respect.

“Decommissioning the monument reflects our commitment to ensuring that all members of our community feel safe and respected.”

Community engagement

The Municipality engaged in a public consultation process, including surveys, public meetings, and one-on-one community conversations with residents. The feedback overwhelmingly indicated that relocating the monument would not address the concerns of those who feel that its presence in public spaces perpetuates harm.

“We explored various options to provide historical context, including educational plaques and exhibits, but ultimately recognized that these efforts would not change the deeply rooted feelings the monument evokes,” continued Mayor Craig.

“Instead of educating, such displays risk amplifying a painful history, contrary to our community’s inclusive values.”

Ethical considerations

The decision to decommission the Secord Monument aligns with ethical guidance on public displays of controversial historical artifacts. Studies done by those who specialize in controversial historical displays indicate that, while context is important, the continued public display of certain monuments can inadvertently serve as a platform that highlights divisive narratives rather than fostering understanding.

According to a recent study by the Public Ethics Institute, adding historical context to controversial monuments does not necessarily educate the public but often serves as an unwanted reminder of the atrocities. This insight, coupled with community feedback, strongly influenced Council’s decision.

Focusing on inclusivity

The Municipality of Kincardine remains committed to fostering an inclusive environment where all residents feel valued. This decision is a step toward ensuring that our public spaces reflect our shared values and serve as places of unity, not division.

“We are dedicated to making the Municipality of Kincardine a welcoming community for everyone,” added Mayor Craig. “While we cannot erase history, we can choose how we present it in a way that reflects the values we hold dear.”

Looking forward

The Municipality will continue to engage with the community on matters of historical representation and inclusivity, exploring alternate ways to educate and honour our past without compromising the principals that make the Municipality of Kincardine a vibrant and inclusive place to live.

For further information, visit the Secord Monument webpage.

- 30 -

Media Inquiries:
Kenneth Craig, Mayor
Municipality of Kincardine
519-396-3468